Auction Information

Online Auction Fraud

eBay sales may have grown 51% last year over the previous year, but general online complaints jumped by 66.6% over the previous year to some 207,000+ complaints in 2004. The Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3), a partnership between the FBI and the National White Collar Crime Center (NW3C), stated in its yearly report that 71.2% of all complaints received pertained to auctions.

Online fraud is a growing problem on the internet and the auction segment is far from immune. The IC3 reports that most complaints consist of late or no shipment of products, items that don't match advertised condition and bogus payment or escrow services.

If you decide to offer "all items to be shipped within 24 hours", make sure you keep your word, and go to great lengths to honestly represent and describe the item in your auctions. Your bidders will appreciate your honesty and it will eventually show up in your feedback.

As consumer fears increase, there are a number of common sense ways to help protect you from fraud, as well as enhance your reputation as a trustworthy seller and set you apart from the crowd.

Watch Out for Bad Checks, Money Orders and Cashiers ChecksYears ago I had a buyer who complained rather loudly when I didn't ship an item as soon as I received the check in the mail. In hind site it was a good decision to hold the shipment since the check ended up being fraudulent. Bad checks, money orders, and cashiers checks are rampant in ecommerce today. The simplest way to offset the danger of bad paper is not to ship the auction item until the check, money order or cashier check clears your bank for payment.


Never accept any overpayments for any item. One of the more popular scams today is for a buyer to send a cashiers check for an amount that is higher than the agreed upon final price. They then claim it was in error and ask the seller to kindly return the overage when the item is shipped. Off goes the item, the overage amount in good money, and the defrauded seller finds out too late the cashiers check was fake.

Use an Escrow Service for High Priced Items

The primary purpose of escrow services is to protect buyers and sellers from fraud. Basically what they do is to accept the money from the buyer and hold it until the buyer receives and approves the merchandise. Please note that fake escrow services are increasing on the internet. If a buyer contacts you after a sale and recommends an escrow service you are not familiar with BEWARE. At present eBay only recommends one escrow company: For information go to

Records, Records, Records

Keeps a copy of every transaction detail from the original auction listing to the last email. You will need that kind of proof to validate your claims if you should find you need to file a complaint.

Protect Yourself by Being Educated

At the very least you need to be knowledgeable about your legal obligations as a seller and familiar with the fraud protections and policies for the auction sites and payment processing services you use. eBay and Paypal have extensive sections on their websites dedicated to fraud policies and protections. You should take the time to read through these or similar information pages for the sites and services you use on a regular basis and be very familiar with the material.

A few of the key recommendations from Paypal's Protection for Sellers section include:

Ship only to the address listed on the Transaction Details page

Use a shipping service with tracking

Check out the buyer's reputation

Accept payment from only one Paypal account per buyer

Limit credit card payments

Enhancing Your Safe Seller Image

Here are a few tips that will help improve your image as a safe seller for your bidders.

Identify Yourself - Make use of the about me pages to let your customers know who you are, how long you've been in business and how much their business means to you. Be honest.

Feedback Ratings - Auction buyers want to see 100% positive feedback.

Methods of Payment - Make it easy for your customers to buy but consider convenience, cost and security in choosing any payment method you offer.

Full Disclosure - Your auction listings should clearly state the condition of the item you're auctioning, your shipping/insurance and return policies.

Bonding programs - A number of bonding programs are available on the internet. One of the more popular is BuySafe ( In a bonding program the seller agrees to certain obligations such as shipping on time, representing the item correctly, and standing behind the transaction. In return the seller can display a seal on their auctions showing bidders they are honest sellers and providing transaction insurance in some cases up to $25,000.

Other programs you should be familiar with include:


If You Become a Victim of Online Fraud

You need to know exactly what should be done in the event you are victimized. Make your plan now, before it happens. The most recommended steps to take if you are victimized are listed below but please keep in mind these are general recommendations and you should have you own plan based on your needs.

File a complaint with your auction site
File a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission
File a complaint with the IC3
File a complaint with the National Fraud Information Center
Contact your local and state law enforcement agencies
Contact the local and state law enforcement agencies in the perpetrator's home area
File a complaint with the shipping company you used
It the perpetrator is a business and a member of the Better Business Bureau you should also file a complaint there.

Further reading

Paypal Seller Protection Policy (go to your Paypal account)

FTC recommendations

To read the entire 2004 IC3 Internet Fraud Report

More Important Fraud Links

Find Your Local Police
FBI Internet Fraud Unit
FTC Internet Fraud Unit
USPS Mail Fraud

© Copyright 2005 Steven Woodward - All Rights Reserved

Steven Woodward is the owner, editor and publisher of the Auction Sellers Network (ASN); a web site for individuals and companies who are serious about utilizing the online auction marketplace for their business. In addition to topical articles, ASN provides an extensive resource center, news feeds, member forums and classified ads. For more information or to become a member please visit

No permission is needed to reproduce an unedited copy of this article as long the About the Author tag is left intact and included. We do request that we be informed where it is posted and reciprocal links will be considered.


artnet News

Kenny Schachter On London's February Auctions: The Sky Is Falling—Or Is It?
artnet News
Breaking news: stocks take a historic plunge amid a global rout and oil slumps to a 13-year low. Even more shocking is that the art market squeaked by during the latest spate of mid-term London auctions, markedly less in volume than last year, with ...
London Auctions Confirm a Cooling Art Market—and the 9 Other Biggest Art News Stories This WeekArtsy

all 2 news articles »

Wall Street Journal

London Art Auctions Show Market in a Correction
Wall Street Journal
London. The second week of the big art auctions here got off to an ominous start at Phillips on Tuesday, when a seller withdrew a Damien Hirst medicine cabinet with a title that seemed to match collectors' moods: “In Search of Reality.” That theme ...

and more »

Zanesville Times Recorder

Eastside auctions chairs for ministry programs
Zanesville Times Recorder
ZANESVILLE - It's not often you'll see so many types of chairs in one place: wooden chairs, kitchen chairs, dog chairs, lounge chairs and even a toilet.On Friday, shoppers at the Colony Square Mall perused the display on the south end. Those intrigued ...
Eastside Community Ministry's CHAIR-ity AuctionWHIZ

all 2 news articles »

Coin World

Stack's Bowers Galleries acquires Manifest Auctions | Coin World
Coin World
Stack's Bowers Galleries purchased the assets of Manifest Auctions of Greenville, S.C., a firm's whose recent auction offerings including a previously unknown $10 national bank note from the First National Bank of Colorado Springs (Colorado).

and more »

Grand Rapids Business Journal (subscription)

College auctions surplus inventory
Grand Rapids Business Journal (subscription)
A community college in the region is auctioning excess inventory after acquiring three urban buildings. The Muskegon Community College, or MCC, Physical Plant department has contracted with Byron Center-based to host an online auction on ...

and more »


Comic With Spider-Man's First Appearance Could Be the Hero's Most Expensive Ever
So huge, in fact, that issues of 1962's Amazing Fantasy #15—which not only features Spidey's first showing, but also his Uncle Ben and Aunt May's—could shatter previous auction records and sell for over $400,000 at Heritage Auctions' February 18-20 ...

and more »


RIVERSIDE: Manheim auctions off classic cars at 'hundred grander'
Facilities: 10 auction lanes, full mechanical shop, paint and body shop, detail facility. Xeriscaping: As part of its expansion, Manheim Riverside replaced 6 acres of turf grass with plants that require less irrigation. Auctions: Eight monthly, with ...

Don't buy that 911 just yet: What Scottsdale auctions' sales declines mean for collectors
On the heels of the first retreat in five years for overall auction sales in Pebble Beach last August, the collector car market was officially in uncertain territory as the big Scottsdale auctions approached in late January. Like Monterey 2015, the ...

Autoblog (blog)

Last Lamborghini Diablo of the 20th century heads to auction
Autoblog (blog)
Even among rare sports cars, some examples are simply more special than others because of their place in history, and for Lamborghini fans this 1999 Diablo SV might be something truly exceptional. Silverstone Auctions claims this is the final Diablo SV ...
Last "true" Lamborghini for
Last Pre-VW-Era Lamborghini Diablo SV Headed to AuctionMotor Trend
Final “True” Lamborghini is Being Auctioned OffduPont REGISTRY (blog)
Fox News -Carscoops (blog) -New Car Net
all 23 news articles »

Middle market shines through during week of uncertainty at London auctions
Art Newspaper
Despite a concerted effort to raise the profile of the five women artusts in the auction, they made a meagre ÂŁ119,000, just 2.2% of the ÂŁ5.3m total. A grim reminder of where women artists stand in the market today, Germaine Richier's apocalyptic bronze ...

and more »

Google News

home | site map
© 2006